mordicai caeli (mordicai) wrote,
mordicai caeli
mordicai

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Nai Hiruvalyë Valimar.

The Ocean at the End of the Lane by Neil Gaiman.

Eye of the needle:
The Grey Witches' one eye.
It's prick is their tooth.

This was Beatrice's pick for Eleven-Books Club & reactions to it ranged from loving it to thinking it was another typical Gaiman. Me? I think this is the best of Neil Gaiman's non-comic book work. Coraline was the previous champ, but I think this deposes it & it is a damn sight better than his other adult novels, which I find generally acceptable but unremarkable, except for the fact that he has a problem ending books. See also "oh crap am I like 500 pages into this thing? I better craft a five page ad hoc conclusion. Um!" in American Gods by way of example. Ocean at the End of the Lane actually starts ramping up to a conclusion about three-fourths of the way in, it actually has a third act & an epilogue, so just on structure alone it wins. Then there are a lot of the usual Gaiman flourishes; he has an eye for detail, for example, so the inclusion of gas lamps in children's rooms & getting zapped by an electric fence really ring true. Similarly, Gaiman has a way of failing to describe things that I find really, really effective, by which I mean the impressionistic style he uses to describe Skarthach of the Keep who we call Ursula Monkton, or the way he fails to describe the faces-maws-mouths-horrors of the Hunger Birds. I think Ocean... is his Gene Wolfe frame-story-- what is up with this adult guy who is a clear author stand-in-- with a Madeleine L'Engle center. Maybe it is just the Three-in-One, though.



Gaiman goes for deep archetypes, & the Fates are it; after reading The Kindly Ones you can't be too surprised. The Norns, the Graeae, the Furies, the Morrigan, call them what you will, Mother, Maiden & Crone. Then the Hunger Birds, the varmints, the Cleaners which I think are pretty clearly just angels. I also really liked the rumors of the Hempstock's origins; immigrant story, no Atlantis, no Krypton, no Faerie! Not to mention that it is a "wicked stepmother" tale, only you know, in the modern context of adultery. & it comes complete with a Narnian Stone Table bit, "you know the Deep Magic but I know a deeper law" stuff from Granny. Our big sticking point was: do you hold the father & sister accountable for their actions? fatbutts certainly did, but I think-- as we see the whole town in the spirit's grip-- that they are utterly & thoroughly enchanted. It was a fun session but I think we mostly just talked about bits we like more than had things to disagree about. Oh & poor bunny Jenny broke her toe! Stubbing it on furniture. Pretty good attendance; me, Jennifer, Liz, Lilly, Beatrice, May, with Terra, littlewashu & carmyarmyofme on Hangouts, which I think is too many people, frankly, but then, I also couldn't get Hangouts to export audio to the television properly, again, so I was already super angry at Hangouts. A bunch of wine, a bunch of Chinese food, & a bunch of chit-chat. We ended up having a fairly late night just shooting the breeze. (Photos courtesy of Jennifer.)

Tags: 11books, 11booksclub, books, gaiman, haiku
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 2 comments