mordicai caeli (mordicai) wrote,
mordicai caeli

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Deinonychus Bones!

Yesterday was the Eleven-Books Club meet-up for fatbutts' first pick, Anya's Ghost by Vera Brosgol. I didn't re-review it; in fact, I more re-skimmed it than re-read it. Guilty, guilty, guilty! Still, it left me pretty conversant. We decided on the three themes as "immigrant story, sexual awakening & the supernatural" & argued over whether they should have been more interwoven or if the compartmentalization of them reflected a sort of "home life, school life, after-school life" division that had a certain verisimilitude. The art was roundly applauded & the font being called "helverica" was groaned at, once the confusion was sorted out. Siobhan was a favorite, as was the fact that the "popular girl" was not painted in start moral black & white. The biggest flaw, people said, was that once the supernatural elements turned "bad" the book was pretty clearly laid out with no surprises. The ghost was just a "psycho" with no real empathizable motivations...& then Anya gets self-confidence & stops smoking. A little pat. The book is on an interesting line between middle-grade & YA, & straddles it well, but some people thought maybe it was the middle-grade part, influencing the ending, while others thought there were plenty of middle-grade books with more ambiguous endings. I mostly compare middle-grade endings to A Wrinkle in Time personally, & I thought while it was a little "tied up in a bow" that I was okay with it. Let me see, rolecall; Beatrice was first, with Girl Scout cookies. Then Lilly came, with doughnuts. carmyarmyofme brought beer with her. Jennifer was next; well, she was just out buying yogurt & berries & phyllo shells & seaweed. fordmadoxfraud showed up & probably brought something, but I think we ate most of his hors d'œuvre at the big AD&D finale. Terra was awake over in China & so we dialed her in. Mostly so Lilly could booty dance for her, I think. Next time we'll have new members, oh la la, & Jennifer already picked the book: Art Girls are Easy, by Julie Klausner.
Tags: 11booksclub
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.