mordicai caeli (mordicai) wrote,
mordicai caeli

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Oubliette: If You Only Knew the Power of the Dark Side.

So lately I've been grappling with the question of cost, of resource management. Questions like whether I need a new Attribute for Potency, or a new pool for Character Traits. That might all be some fairly advanced stuff, with a narrow window of interest; I want to talk about the philosophy of game design, but I end up talking about my Oubliette campaign, particularly. To sort of break out of that mold, I have had a particular nagging thought that I figured I'd ruminate on. It isn't actually any more accessible-- in practice, I think of it in World of Darkness terms-- but you could carry through the logic to other systems. I'll try to keep my notions generic, or at least to toss out parallels when things start getting a little big too specific.

This sort of goes along with the idea of Marks that I mentioned previously; long term consequences for contact with the supernatural. Or the paranormal, even, if we go with my proposed nomenclature. What I have been thinking about is-- levying serious costs against Players. Vampire: the Requiem has the most notable one-- it costs a dot of Willpower to make another vampire. Not a point-- a chunk of the attribute. In in Dungeons & Dragons terms, that is like permanent attribute drain. Or is it? You can buy it back with Experience-- eight points, which is a little less than three adventures worth-- so it is more like Magic Item creation, or spells with Experience Points cost, isn't it? Which is a shame-- I've never liked "Experience Damage" as a magic system, though I will admit that it might keep wizards rare at the table. What about actual Attribute Damage, though?

I just keep thinking about possibilities, & fiction where those have played out. Permanent damage to Health-- or a permanent lower of Hit Points-- to reflect the rot of the Emperor in Star Wars? With corresponding benefits; guy can see the future & shoot lightning. A permanent loss of Humanity? Well, first Humanity would have to have some in-game value for that to really be compelling, but the struggle with hubris & inhumanity is fine & dandy. Permanent looses of Willpower are fine-- I tested it on Balthazar in my last campaign-- until you start coupling it with using Willpower as your main resource pool. Then it gets wonky...though half-crazed paranormal powerhouses can lend a cool Akira vibe. The more I think about it, gets wonky. Maybe an easier way of approaching this is to consider reverse Experience? That is, tempting a place with lichdom, slowly selling off their Health dots for Experience points to buy powers? A good road to the Dark Side, maybe? Temptation!
Tags: attributes, house rules, marks, oubliette, wod

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.