mordicai caeli (mordicai) wrote,
mordicai caeli
mordicai

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Urban Legends. (1)

Glimpses of the Unknown by White Wolf.

O Doktor Tophet!
In your harlequinade mask,
geiselghastly robes.

I ordered this for a couple of reasons-- well, two big ones, really. First, I've been interested in the Unknown as a hallmark of separating The Supernatural & the Paranormal-- that is, having rules & logic define vampires may make them Paranormal, but the things without rules & logic are Supernatural-- or at least, when you don't know them. The other reason I got this was because the back jacket copy mentions Mirrors, which is the best sourcebook for the New World of Darkness hands down. I was hoping it would be something like Mythologies was for Vampire, but if it as more like Infinite Macabre, that would be aces as well. Unfortunately, it isn't really either; instead, it is a collection of hooks, of story seeds & sample plot lines, which isn't something I really needed. I realize that since I rum my Oubliette campaign on the World of Darkness, but without using any of their worldbuilding, that I'm not their target customer, but I was hoping this would scratch an itch, & it didn't. On the plus side-- this is the first of their "print on demand" titles I've ordered, & I'm satisfied with that process; well, the book doesn't have its title on the spine, & there are "notes" pages in the back as filler, neither of which is my favorite, but at least I was able to get it, & the binding quality is decent. Thanks, Lightning Source!

The book is divided into sections, by game line. The first section is just for straight-up mortal games in the World of Darkness. Some of the plots here are banal, but "She Lives" is a good one, as is the idea of a "bottle game" in a prison. The rules crunch here is miscellaneous paranormal phenomenon. The Vampire: the Requiem section is pretty hit or miss-- lots of the ideas are really obvious, but "Stolen Time" is an interesting way of playing on the fog of memory & "Lucky 13" manages to make an energy drink ominous & interesting. The Supernatural Lore Merit is useless, though. The Werewolf: the Forsaken chapter has "Earworm," which is the only decent story seed, though "The Gardener" might be a good fit in another campaign. The Mage: the Awakening has a hook for dragons, but other than that, you can skip it. The advice is basically "run a Mage campaign!" Promethean: the Created would actually be a good fit for The Gardener mentioned earlier. Still, I'm not impressed with these hooks, either-- they are all pretty much something I'd expect any Storyteller to be able to come up with on their own. Seriously, a spooky cat? That gets half a page? The use of foreshadowing & metanarrative in "Backwards from Redemption" is decent, though. The sample Athanor, though? Seems overpowered. Changeling: the Lost shares the same problems-- a lot of these ideas aren't particularly...unknown? They just seem like...ideas, & not even particularly inventive ones.

It is sort of a problem through the book in general. Hunger: the Vigil is already build with a generic template for monsters, meaning that all the monsters are original & unknown by default...which undercuts a lot of the sample ideas here. Heck, one of the plots is just "why don't you look at the Slasher book!" Oh...okay? I like that book, but that isn't a very good...pitch for a story? The problem continues with the section for Geist: the Sin-Eaters...all the sample hooks & brainstorming is basically "oh, man, how about you have those guys mess around with ghosts?" I know man, that is what those guys are up to. They are the ghost-dudes. That isn't a "glimpse of the unknown," that is a glimpse of the totally known. In fact, the core premise of that game. I don't even. However! All that changes when you get to the bit of the book about Innocents. First off, kudos for giving that book more attention-- "playing as kids in the World of Darkness" is a great idea on its own. Then having a list of field trips that could go wrong? Useful! Having a bit about a kid whose reflection's eyes seem terrified? Okay, yikes, shivers. & then "Kids' Jail," is just a home run; that is a great mini-campaign idea. There is a final section on plot seeds for Mirrors-- the sample settings (or "shards") presented in that book. Some of them are fine; again, dragons are cool, & "reality bleed" is neat. Doing a Fringe sort of "realities collide" story could work. Then again, the reluctant messiah notion of "The Unlikely Savior" & the last bastion pitch of "The Light at the End of Days" are another page of text that I don't think anyone who would run a post-apocalyptic campaign would need suggested to them.
Tags: books, haiku, rpgs, wod
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 0 comments