mordicai caeli (mordicai) wrote,
mordicai caeli
mordicai

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Always Winter, Never Christmas. (118)

Winter Witch by Elaine Cunningham & Dave Gross.

Baba Yaga's get:
Gloriana & Clwdwg,
hidden Parsifal.

I suppose Elaine Cunningham is a bigger name, but I picked this up because I always have a good time reading Dave Gross' books. When I say "picked up," I mean "took off the shelf & read," because I originally picked-it-up-as-in-obtained-it when Dave was in town & ran a Pathfinder one-shot. Just putting my biases out in front, but I should be clear-- I'm not so much biased towards these books because I like Dave as I am biased to like Dave because of these books. It was reading this one that I realized what Gross' work most reminds me of, what the biggest influence on it seems to be, at least to me-- Fritz Leiber's Lankhmar books. Ellafif's upbringing in the austere & icy north made me think of Fafhrd's origin story, which then made me consider Count Varian Jeggare & Radovan as a sort of Gray Mouser & Fafhrd duo-- less scoundrels, but a similar vein of weird adventure. Something I find myself remarking upon fairly frequently is convergent evolution. Pathfinder has a tendency to pepper science-fantasy & pulpy space-opera in the background of their setting, which line up a lot of the times to some similar appendages in my campaign, Oubliette. This doesn't have that angle, but I found myself thinking of Kobold Quarterly's Zobek while the story was in the city of Korvosa, & as the narrative moved up to the lands of the Linnorm Kings & Irrisen, my mind drifted to Voyce's Northlands. It speaks well to everyone's understanding of archetypes; the harsh north with heavy Norse elements, the cosmopolitan city with imps & pseudodragons fighting on rooftops, & Gypsy-like caravans threading between. It is the use of tropes, rather than the abuse of them, providing a latching on point for the reader's imagination.

I think the most compelling thing to me about this novel-- probably because I'm a worldbuilder at heart-- is the peppering of details. For instance, the somatic elements, the gestures & physicality of culture. The crossing of the chest for the symbolic wings of the goddess Desna, for instance, really stands out; it is used as a similar gesture to the Christian cross over the heart, but that simple action just lends a lot of believable colour. I have to consider it as one of Dave Gross' contributions, comparing it to Radovan's "throwing the tines," a lewd gesture similar to the flipped middle finger. There are bigger ideas that really draw me in as well-- the cold north's cities as, paradoxically, lush & steamy oases, like great greenhouses with ice roofs, or the book's reliance on cannibalism as an element of horror, combining (demi)human taboos with trolls & winter wolves to hold up an inhuman mirror to the rest of the world. Not for nothing, but I've had a thing for Irrisen ever since I read The Inner Sea Primer. It is those bits & pieces that make the whole world palatable; they are the salt & pepper that bring out the best flavors of the meat. Yes, tell me about the bearskin rugs on the floor! I want to know about the decorations sewn into the hem of her tunic, absolutely! Oh, they leave goat's milk & cinnamon rolls at the corners of their camp so mischievous gnomes don't harass them? These simple little flourishes are better than one fat anchor; they are a myriad of tether points, stitching the characters, game setting, narrative conventions & plot together into a whole.
Tags: books, cunningham, dnd, gross, haiku, paizo, pathfinder
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 2 comments