mordicai caeli (mordicai) wrote,
mordicai caeli

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Oubliette: On Race & Species.

So here is the thing. In order to be a Drow-- a dark elf-- you need three things, as far as I'm concerned. You need to be a dark skinned elf, who lives underground, & who worships spiders. You can change one of the things-- but if you change two, then you aren't Drow any more. Drow cultists of the Elder Elemental Eye? Still living underground, still dark skinned elves. Xen'drik Drow, in Eberron? Live above ground & worship scorpions? Bzzt. No, now you are just black elves, guys-- though okay, "scorpion" is pretty close to "spider." Even someone like Drizzt-- who doesn't live underground or worship the Spider Queen-- it defined by his iconoclasm, right? So, same thing. These definitions are a little bit plastic, but I think it shows how important culture & environment are to defining a fantasy race. It is something I've been thinking about, spurred on by musing about Kingdom Strange. Something that has, in fact, always bugged me. Monoculture. "Dwarves are this way. They live underground, are great craftsmen, are greedy, & hate goblins & giants & dislike elves." "Elves are such & such a way. They love nature, & live in trees, & are good with bows. They hate orcs & dislike dwarves." It is something that I steer away from in Oubliette. I want every race to be just as diverse as humans. Humans, I should say, because in a world with fantasy races I think you need that capital letter. Similarly, I want every world to be as diverse as Earth. Back to races, though-- one of the races in Oubliette are the Demi, who are...small. They have other biological tendencies-- more emphasis on cultural roles, a certain alien mind-set. In game terms, they get less Attributes & more Skills & a Derangement that gives them back Willpower if they indulge it. In fact, Demi isn't a "race," but a species. That is an important difference. Now with the Demi as my "hardware," I can run other fantasy tropes on them as "software." A subterranean tribe of Demi who have a mental inclination toward Obsession & a cultural preference for beards? Dwarves! A hive of Demi living in advanced saucer shaped ships with a predilection towards human experimentation? Greys! Isolated island dwellers who farm bananas who live behind waterfalls & have a phobia of owls? Menehune! Monoculture can be cool-- "all the Dragonborn are the scions of their fallen Empire"-- but its proliferation is kind of goofy. You can see that fact wiggle its way into the mythology of Dungeons & Dragons-- heck, in 4e you've got Elves (Wood Elves), Eladrin (High Elves) & Drow (Dark Elves). Those don't all have to be races, they could just as easily be cultures. Some systems or settings make it a feature of Humans-- Elves & Dwarves are all alike, but Humans are diverse, Humans have cultures. That is one way to handle it, but I think the best way is to have your "races" be "species," & then have cultures for them...exist. It adds verisimilitude, if you ask me.
Tags: dnd, house rules, oubliette, races, setting

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.