mordicai caeli (mordicai) wrote,
mordicai caeli

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Lamashtu wept. (18)

Misfit Monsters Redeemed by Colin McComb, Rob McCreary & James L. Sutter.

Giant space hamsters!
Gnomes use them to fly in space.
That's a good monster.

The ...Revisted series is great; I think we can all say that. In fact, I would argue--& Misfit Monsters Redeemed does argue-- that Paizo really claimed its space in the gaming market starting with its goblins. Wayne Reynold's art, a Gremlins sensibility, & James Jacob's brutal nursery rhyme songs all came together. It showed the versatility of the hobby-- unique portrayals of broad ideas, iterated storytelling, all that. Pathfinder gave the goblins a hook-- a theme that anyone could readily use. You could read about the goblins & just get it. Creepy mischief, goofy malice-- it was a seed, something that planted itself in your imagination & let your mind bear hideous fruit. It didn't hurt that I am something of a goblin aficionado, & they struck a similar chord to my own interpretation. That was just the start-- Pathfinder made a niche out of taking a view askew approach to the classic archetypes of fantasy roleplaying. Giving something that wasn't too strange, but provided a new take on old monsters, classes, & cliches. Eventually, Misfit Monsters Redeemed was inevitable. The book is like a dare, issued to themselves. Take some of the most ridiculed monsters & try to make them awesome. Lets not mess around here-- some of these monsters are stupid. Some monsters are dumb but gamers like them anyhow-- & those were eliminated. Sorry gelatinous cube, but everyone likes you despite how silly you are. Flumphs on the other hand are right on. Some of the retrofits are easy, & more a matter of taking something goofy like a flail snail & treating it seriously. Some remind me of other creatures-- adherers just remind me of kaorti, not that I'm complaining. Alien glue monsters are creepy. The Wolf-in-Sheep's-Clothing embraces that direction-- if you are going to make something alien, pull out all the stops. Hell, give it chainsaw teeth. The "Lurking Ray" is the real success story of the book. Taking Trappers & Lurkers Above-- evil monstrous floor & ceiling mimics, respectively-- & pairing them with the Executioner's Hood to make one monster at various stages in its life cycle? That is economy of narrative, that is, & it succeeds splendidly at making otherwise silly monsters into something at once spooky & plausible.

Tags: books, dnd, haiku, paizo, pathfinder, rpgs

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.