mordicai caeli (mordicai) wrote,
mordicai caeli

  • Mood:
  • Music:

(3rd Stage)

Ethics have been on my mind; largely martak's Chaos, Hostility, & Murder: A Love Story & The Ethicist are to blame, in the grander scope of things. In the grandest scope of things is the fact that Evil & Skeptisicm are questions; that Nihilism & Solipsism beg further consideration. Most immediately though, I've been thinking about The Prisoner's Dilemma. Not the classic version, but rather the iterative & stranger thought experiments that have spun out of it. I like the elegence of the Prisoner's Dilemma once it is uncoupled from its strict constraints. I like when it starts blooming, starts showing the patterns of complexity. It has been directly on my mind since I watched a clip of the very finale of Bachelor Pad. Now, I don't know anything about that show, but in the following clip, the host lays out a pretty basic version of the Prisoner's Dilemma, & here is the hook: the audience & contestants lose their mind. I've taken it for granted, so seeing people presented with it for the first time is really refreshing, & more to the point, really interesting, because they haven't considered it before. They haven't taken it as a given that they must be prepared for the set-up. Anyhow, it is worth watching:

So Robert Axelrod (In The Evolution of Cooperation, which I confess I haven't read) lays out four descriptive conditions of strategies that do well at The Prisoner's Dilemma: they are Nice, which is to say it presupposes cooperation, unless there is reason not to; they are Retaliating, in that if the other player defects, they punish with their own defection; they are Forgiving, so that they can put aside relaliating & go back to cooperating when the other side starts cooperating; & they are Non-envious, which is to say they don't judge off of the "cheaters" points, but rather optimizing their own. Those are pretty decent evidence for the success of Ethics; then again, that is sort of the point of game theory. This is the sort of thing that makes me angry about state bailouts & light punishments for white collar crime; those are the defections we should be punishing. The whole point of government, if you ask me, can be reduced to "make cooperating the best option & defecting the worst option." Do it with the carrot & the stick, use every trick in the book. Anyhow; I think about the Dilemma a lot, so seeing it with fresh eyes was fun.
Tags: ideology, videos
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.