mordicai caeli (mordicai) wrote,
mordicai caeli

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Honey & Locusts. (79)

Shades of Milk and Honey by Mary Robinette Kowal.

Canaan is England!
Victoria's Hosanna:
Lo! Pax Britannia!

The obvious comparison here is to Jane Austen, which leads me to a bit of a confession. Since I went to college for Forensic Anthropology, instead of something like English, I missed "The Canon." I've never read things like Wuthering Heights or Pride & Predjudice or Jane Eyre. I did however read the more modern comparison-- Jonathon Strange & Mister Norrell-- & I find it apt. I haven't read the classics I probably ought to have, but I can tell you that this reads like I imagine them to be like. Shades of Milk & Honey is ostensibly a fantasy novel, though viewed in a certain light it is much more a romance, or a historical novel, or magical realism-- & I think that its charm is the difficulty in pegging it down. Don't be fooled by the Tor mountain on the spine-- this is not a novel of blue glowing swords clashing in an epic conflict. No, this isn't Dungeons & Dragons but rather Drawing Rooms & Debutantes. It is a novel of courtship by calling card, a discourse on the nature of Art, a slow social dance with just a dash of glamour. A mystery of mistaken lovers & family disgraces set amidst (literal) illusions & deceptions. That is the strength of the narrative-- it is a small story, a personal story that takes place between neighbors. You won't be surprised by any of the twists, & if you keep looking for a big reveal, you won't find one-- the reader's jaded modern senses & sensibilities (see what I did there?) unravel the plot before the more dignified characters of the story do. Our hero is Miss Jane Ellsworth, & the author Mary Robinette Kowal manages to pull of the careful teeter-totter such a character requires. A female character set during the height of patriarchy, constrained by social obligations & manners, but self-determined, strong. Without giving into anarchronism, or portraying an iconoclast who defies convention, Robinette Kowal manages to keep the scales level-- Miss Elssworth isn't suddenly given to modern notions of feminism; but there is little doubt to her intellegence & will. Her lot in life is difficult-- as a woman, as a plain woman, & as a talented woman-- but we are given her without apology, without allowances made for our expectations. There is no cheating. She is a "proper lady" operating entirely in her historical context, & a thoroughly compelling character because of it.
Tags: books, haiku, kowal

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.