mordicai caeli (mordicai) wrote,
mordicai caeli
mordicai

  • Mood:
  • Music:

"call me highway, call me conduit..." (49)

Excession by Iain M. Banks.

"My god! Its full of..."
HAL 9000, Culture Mind,
had already left.

My most recently read Culture novel; super rewarding but also a deeply imperfect novel. As fordmadoxfraud summarizes in his review, this is the story of The Culture versus the Monolith from 2001: A Space Odyssey. Now, anyone who knows me better than a little knows that I've canonized 2001-- I don't think there is a greater work of cinema fiction, & the tapes of the moon landing are the only piece of non-fiction film that surpasses it. The Culture of course are the post-scarcity hedonistic answer to utopian science-fiction: The Culture is utopian but the universe isn't some peaceful place of hugs & puppies. The balance between the nihilistic facts of the universe & the extraordinary resources of The Culture are usually two of the legs on a Culture novels tripod; the third varying, usually related to contact with another species, a barbarian species that The Culture is trying to uplift. I say "contact" but probably should say "Contact"-- Contact being the branch of The Culture with the most cache, along with their dirty works division, Special Circumstances. Excession is a story of contact, but between The Culture & something more advanced, what they call an Out Of Context Problem-- like Cortez showing up on the Aztec's doorstep. The sort of thing that might just mean the end of your civilization.

I mentioned that I had problems with this book, so let me get them out of the way, with the caveat that I still stayed up late last night finishing this-- it is a very compelling read. The biggest mis-step this book makes is in humanizing The Minds. See, The Culture is ran by these sort of all-powerful synthetic intelligences, called Minds. Humans designed a super-smart AI they could barely understand, which designed a super-smart AI it could barely understand, ad infinitum. The Minds are, for all intents & purposes, gods...which is why anthropomorphizing them is such a failure. First & foremost, there is a sort of "email" vibe in the Mind-to-Mind communications; the book was published in 1996, & it really seems dated. Secondly, well-- The Minds are characters. Which just doesn't work. I'm sorry but an essentially unlimited intellect should have probably put contingency plans in place for something like this, or shouldn't be as doubtful or-- well, if The Minds were people I'd say they were acting fine, but The Minds aren't people. Do you take my meaning? It doesn't work to portray them that way. That being said, on the topic of characters, I think the Elencher drone Sisela Ytheleus 1/2 is my favorite character from any of the Culture novels. Its cleverness in the face of annihilation & oblivion, time after time, is super heroic & compelling; I was shouting advice to the book as I read its bits. "Dump the biological core into the anti-matter! Do it!" That sort of thing. & for all that I criticize The Minds, I did like Sleeper Service, who actually had acted the most "Mind-like;" for that matter Grey Matter's super creepy mind-control & torture fetish was...well, super creepy; & heck while I'm handing out merit badges, Killing Time being so aware of its atavism as a warship was a nice touch. It isn't the personalities of The Minds I object to, but rather their level of operation-- they behave like humans or 1:1 drones, you know?
Tags: banks, books, culture, haiku
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 7 comments