mordicai caeli (mordicai) wrote,
mordicai caeli
mordicai

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Hated Noah! (14)

Changing Breeds by White Wolf Studios.

Hanuman, & the
Bear-King, the Spider-Woman
& dread Baphomet.

The Good. Well, the original reason I wanted this book remains the most valid-- there is a grab-bag of powers. Dotted powers with an animal bent, fit for all kinds of uses-- shapechangers, sure, but there is plenty of meat to be used for gene-spliced hybrids, or anthropomorphic fantasy races, or whatever. The book sort of snidely makes comments that "radioactive hamsters are right out," but I couldn't help but think about Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Besides that, there are a few myths & legends planted in the "breeds" section-- rhinocerouses coming from two orphan twins who were burned to death? Or the leopard-godlings of Aztec mythology? Nicely done.

The Bad. Remember that snide comment about no "radioactive hamsters?" Screw you buddy, I'll do whatever I want to. Okay, I get that you want to avoid the sort of silliness that sometimes sprouted up in the Old World of Darkness, so I won't grudge too hard, but could you get this book an editor? There are way too many winks at the reader, & a whole lot of stupid sweeping statements-- "animals are masters at manipulating human emotions..." What the hell are you talking about? No they aren't! Ruleswise, there isn't any balance, & the book sort of sneers at the idea that an elephat-shifter & a mouse-shifter would be balanced. Um, you could, guys, it wouldn't be hard. You could balance the attribute modifications with penalties, you could balance the powers better. Like-- multiple limbs granting multiple actions? After all the trouble to remove multiple actions from things like Celerity?

The Ugly. Listen, I'm a hard guy to embarass on the train. I'll read my books with dragons fighting robots, I don't even care. The art in this book though...Well, I mean, you're already in a difficult position. Anthropomorphic animals. You could try harder not to be...furries. I mean, instead of having a sexy cat lady? You could have a terrifying monster. Or instead of having all those naked were-people you could...not? Seriously, there is a deer-lady & a caribou man who are just porn'd up, with little tufts of fur over their bits. The layout isn't great either, but the New WoD books as a rule haven't been well organized.
Tags: books, rpgs, wod
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 7 comments