mordicai caeli (mordicai) wrote,
mordicai caeli
mordicai

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Vim & Vigour. (14; 4:10 )

Valour & Vanity by Mary Robinette Kowal.

It's not true that
you can't con an honest man.
But can he con you?

You know I like Robinette Kowal's "Jane Austen with illusion magic" novels. On, before I go on, did I mention that I watched Austenland, the movie made out of that Shannon Hale book? I don't think it had the budget to be all that great, but as far as popcorn goes, I liked it fine. Maybe worth throwing on Netflix, if you like romcoms or Austen or just feel like it. Okay, back to Valour & Vanity. Oh, so extraneous u's, British spelling! I've got a bunch scattered in my spelling. I don't know why; I remember deciding to rep the ampersand, & I am not shy about owning up to my pretentions, so I would if I could. The nearest guess I can come up with is that I'm a terrible speller & I just learned the rule wrong, or maybe British anthropology texts? I certainly have seen "artefact" a lot. A mystery to me, & & can't decide if I should try to scrub it out or just accept it as it is. I err with the later.

This time really back to V&V. So you remember the premise? Jane is a plausibly feminist woman in Regency England, & she has picaresque adventures with her husband, Sir Vincent...& they are both Glamourists, masters of illusion (the only kind of magic that exists-- or at least that we've seen so far). Romance is a theme, but so is adventure; they've tangled with Napoleon! Unlike a lot of Regency writing, Robinette Kowal constantly puts her characters at the intersection of race, class & gender issues. When ends up resulting is a fun story with complexity & depth. Plus also, for instance, pirates. Or Lord Byron, in this one. Byron is mentioned early, & his first appearance had me in stitches.

I liked this book quite a bit but I should tell you: the last act is the best one. When I was talking about The Goblin Emperor, I mentioned how stupid protagonists are my pet peeve, yeah? Well, I take it back when it comes to Mary Robinette Kowal's characters; their flaws are her strong suit. It could be easy to turn Jane into a Mary Sue, into an anachronistic character who uses modern feminism to knock down straw men, but Jane is a character, with her own biases & blind spots. So when I start yelling at the book-- "no, can't you see, gasp, sputter!"-- it is, what do the kids call it: dramatic irony. & thank heavens, she doesn't leave the reader on the hook too long. The characters do figure it out & then they do something about it. They get all Heist Movie. They provide...leverage.
Tags: books, haiku, kowal
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 6 comments