mordicai caeli (mordicai) wrote,
mordicai caeli
mordicai

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Much Ado About Whedon.



It seems almost beside the point to talk about this movie. People fall pretty squarely into two camps, as far as I can tell: one group is predisposed to like it because...well, it is Joss Whedon doing Shakespeare with his stable of actors, & the other group...wants to hate on it from a sort of too-cool-for-school reactionary attitude. I...am a member of the former group. A bunch of actors I like got together to do a play I like! It is fun. Jennifer & I saw Much Ado at Roosevelt Island with Terra & Scott last year; this time it was at the Sunshine with onatopofthings, & we ran into Vicki & Krestyna in line. Here is the thing about Much Ado About Nothing; Twelfth Night is my favorite Shakespeare comedy but Much Ado seems like the only self-aware one. It is the one play where, after the messed up gender stuff happens, people are like "that was not okay." I'll always have a soft spot for Benedick for that reason...& weirdly, it is why Fran Kranz's Claudio was maybe my favorite? I hate Claudio, but Kranz played him with a sort of befuddled earnestness where you could believe he was more of a hapless idiot than anything else...not that being dumb excuses being a misogynist who listens to the obvious villain over your own supposed true love.

I don't mind a little fan service. Giving us Amy Acker as Beatrice & Alexis Denisof as Benedick recalls Wesley & Fred from Angel & that is fun. Yes, it is self-indulgent but it is also a layer of meta-text. Clark Gregg's Leonato & Reed Diamond's Don Pedro were...drunk as hell the whole time. Sean Maher has a distinct unlikability; in Firefly it was used to deal with issues of class, but here it is just blatent, as he's Don John. Riki Lindhome is his Conrad, & they pair them up in a way I found pretty fun; the whole time I was like, "wait, where do I know her from?" & the answer was Garfunkel and Oates, right, got it. Fillion's Dogberry (with Tom Lenk as Verges) didn't blow me away; the clowning wasn't as slapstick on screen as it might have been on stage, & Whedon didn't give it enough awkward camera time for Fillion's hamming it up to sink in. Actually, it was Denisof & Acker's pratfalls that really won me over. Really though I can't complain at all; I wanted to see all of these guys in a Shakespeare play. That is what I was promised & that is what I got. As a side note: Whedon left the "Ethiope" line in, but included a black actress reacting to that line. Which is a sort of funny gag-- again, meta-text-- but did highlight the fact that the cast was lilly white.
Tags: movies, shakespeare
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 2 comments